The Brokers Are Going Broke 💸

Table of Contents

The Brokers Are Going Broke 

Trading commissions are falling for investors, and the sky is falling for brokerages! TD Ameritrade led tumbling broker stocks yesterday as investors questioned if the business model was going obsolete.

Back in the olden days, the stock market was for the few, not the many. Brokerages were as filthy rich as their clients, and routine thousand-dollar investments made a per trade commission of $25 work. However, as the years rolled on, markets became more democratized. Broker business models needed to bend and flex for a new crop of investors.

Commissions have been whittled down to around $6, but now investors have to navigate a minefield of new costs intended to replace them. 1-3% platform fees have become the new norm. That money is taken from the balance of your account every year, so if your portfolio goes up 10%, you only take home 9%. Brokers like Schwab have also declared themselves superstar fund managers and wise financial advisors, getting customers to give them their money and charging an additional fee for the privilege. All this is the stockbroker’s idea of a compromise to the old ways. However, there’s still a problem.

The more you know, the less you pay, and millennial investors aren’t stupid. They want to make fractional, micro-investments investments through free apps. Sleepy broker investor-bases woke up yesterday, selling news that Schwab (-7%) had gone all ‘zero commissions’ on everyone. The likes of TD Ameritrade and E*Trade also need to take massive u-turns with their business models, and that promises pain for shareholders.

The ripple effect may have almost washed away E*Trade (-23%) and TD Ameritrade (-17%), but some opportunists in the market are betting these brokers will fight for their lives and bounce back. Who knows? The customer’s the real winner!

Share:
More Posts
Get your daily Invstr Crunch

Get the market news and updates you need, delivered to your inbox or available on our daily podcast.

Risk Disclosure:

Invstr is not a bank and banking services are provided by Vast Bank, N.A.

Brokerage and Banking services are currently only available to U.S. residents.

Invstr app and web services are provided by Invstr Ltd. Advisory services are provided by Invstr Financial LLC, an investment adviser registered with the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) details of which can be obtained here. Securities brokerage and custody services are provided by Apex Clearing, a broker dealer registered with the SEC and a member of FINRA and SIPC. There is no bank guarantee on securities and securities may lose value.

Investing involves risk and can lead to losses. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Invstr app and web services are provided by Invstr Ltd. Invstr+ advisory services are provided by Invstr Financial LLC, an investment adviser registered with the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC). Securities brokerage and custody services are provided by Apex Clearing, a broker dealer registered with the SEC and a member of FINRA and SIPC. There is no bank guarantee on securities and securities may lose value. Vast Bank N.A. a nationally chartered bank and member of the FDIC, provides the banking products, including the products and services related to digital asset accounts. As with any asset, the value of Digital assets can go up or down and there can be a substantial risk that you lose money buying or holding digital assets. You should carefully consider whether trading or holding Digital assets is suitable for you in light of your financial condition. Your digital account does not support wallet to wallet transferring of your digital assets (i.e. cryptocurrencies) outside the platform. Any Digital Assets in your digital asset account are not insured by any government entities, including but not limited to FDIC or SIPC. The Invstr Visa® Debit Card is issued by Vast Bank, N.A. pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A Inc and may be used everywhere Visa debit cards are accepted. Invstr Ltd, Invstr Financial LLC and Invstr Securities Ltd are subsidiaries of Marketspringpad Holdings (collectively “Invstr”) and Invstr is solely responsible for the application services and website content.

Watchlists provided when users first access the service are not a recommendation to invest. Instead they are provided to help users better navigate the service. Users are free to edit and create their own watchlists. From time to time, Invstr will suggest instruments solely based on an individual’s interest and the interest levels of the Invstr community. The statistical and portfolio builder models generated by Invstr do not reflect actual investment results and are not guarantees of future results. Comments provided by Invstr leaders, influencers or members of the Invstr Community are not recommendations and should not be construed as such. Invstr does not endorse the content or the positions posted by them. Their investment approach, and that of the models provided by Invstr, may be different from yours and may not be appropriate for you.