A Comparable Analysis of Railroad Stocks

Table of Contents


A Comparable Analysis of Railroad Stocks

Disclaimer: This is not investment advice, just one person’s opinion. Always complete thorough analysis on your own before investing and understand the risks associated with an investment.

The focus of this article will be to show how I compare companies to potentially invest in them. I will walk you through how I begin a fundamental analysis of a company’s financials. Before we begin, I will use a lot of jargon and financial ratios, so please check out the vocabulary section at the bottom of the article for definitions.

I chose the railroad industry to look at because it is an easy to understand business, and it is fairly predictable. In addition, railroads could diversify my tech-heavy portfolio and provide strong returns. In fact, Union Pacific wrote in their most recent 10-Q, “we have seen material volume declines from March in autos, intermodal, chemicals, petroleum, coal and metals offset by increases in grain, construction, and pulp and paper products. Demand driven resources will be adjusted to match the volumes and other cost savings initiatives will be implemented in the second quarter”. Thus on the surface, railroads seem to have a potential place in my post-Covid portfolio because so far, they seem to be at least semi-resilient to Covid related demand shocks.

I started my analysis by selecting the largest and most well known publicly traded railroads. I chose, Union Pacific, Kansas City Southern, CSX Corp, Norfolk Southern, Canadian Pacific, and Canadian National. I began by importing balance sheet and income statement data. I then created two tables to compare these companies: one in regard to valuation and another looking at quality.

The valuation table uses trailing 12 month price to earnings ratio (p/e ratio), enterprise value (EV)/sales, EV/EBIT, and EV/EBITDA. The end result of these ratios is to gauge the relative price of the companies compared to their earnings. The quality table looks at debt:equity, leverage, coverage, quick ratio, EBITDA margin, return on assets (ROA), and sales growth. Debt:equity, leverage, and coverage attempt to look at the financial well-being of companies by analyzing their debt levels. The quick ratio looks at cash and cash-like assets relative to upcoming liabilities. EBITDA margin, ROA, and sales growth look at how profitable and efficient these firms are.

Based on just the ratios, and keeping in mind a post-Covid world, the railroads from least to most attractive are Kansas City Southern, Norfolk Southern, Union Pacific, CSX Corp, Canadian Pacific, and Canadian National. Canadian National consistently has the lowest valuation ratios; this means that for every dollar of earnings you are paying among the lowest amounts, and for every dollar of enterprise value, you are paying the lowest amount. In addition, Canadian National has a low amount of debt relative to equity and earnings. For the two years in question, Canadian National has strong EBITDA margin, ROA, and sales growth. The combination of a manageable debt load, and strong profitability as well as efficiency ratios makes Canadian National the strongest ratio railroad, in my opinion. Their one weakness is the low quick ratio, however the company has plenty of earnings to cover interest expense, and it can always issue debt if extra liquidity is needed. The least attractive based on the ratios is Kansas City Southern because it has had the lowest return on assets, and among the lowest EBITDA margins. Kansas City Southern has the highest P/E, EV/EBIT, and EV/EBITDA ratios.

While using financial ratios to value and compare companies is considered “good” practice among finance professionals, it is important to remember there are limitations to ratios. There is a lot of external information that goes into the value of a company in addition to ratios. And much more can affect the future performance of a stock.

Another limitation of this analysis is that the “top 2” – based primarily on ratios – are not available to trade on Invstr. Thus, I am invested in Union Pacific and CSX on Invstr. I like Union Pacific because of its strong profitability and return on assets. Union Pacific also has the largest market cap and has the lowest interest payments relative to its earnings. These two factors give me the confidence to be long regardless of the amount of debt Union Pacific has. I like CSX because of its leading profitability numbers, combined with the highest quick ratio out of the bunch. I am also long CSX because it has the second largest market cap for railroads on Invstr. 

Stay tuned for more industry analyses. And follow my Invstr page @robbieb for trading ideas and commentary on events in financial markets.


P/E: Stock Price/Earnings per share. Measures how much you are paying for a dollar of earnings.

EBIT: Earnings before interest and taxes.

EBITDA: Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.

Enterprise value (EV): market capitalization + preferred equity + minority interest + total debt – cash

EV ratios (EV/sales, EV/EBIT, and EV/EBITDA): Measures how much a company earns relative to the total value of the firm.

Debt:equity: Ratio of how much debt financing a company uses compared to equity.

Leverage (Debt/EBITDA): Measures debt relative to earnings. 

Coverage (Interest expense/EBITDA): Measures how many times a company can cover its interest expense with the most recent earnings.

Quick ratio: Check out my article on the quick ratio.

EBITDA margin (EBITDA/sales): Measure of profitability.

ROA (Net income/Average total assets): Return on assets measures how profitable a company’s assets are at producing revenue.

More Posts
PGA Tour Enters Investment Talks 💪

As reported on Thursday, both Endeavor Group and Fenway Sports have displayed interest and begun discussions to provide investment in the PGA Tour.

Nike Just Didn’t Do It 📉

Providing one of the biggest earnings reports of the week, $140 billion shoe and clothing retailer Nike posted a significant slip.

Market Recap – September 28th 💰

After the 10-year Treasury yield bond fell off from its 15-year high, investors added some value back into the market, focusing all short-term attention on Friday’s PCE price index reading.

The Crude Oil Bust 🛢

Surging global crude oil prices, driven by factors like OPEC+ production cuts have pushed U.S. West Texas Intermediate futures to over $95 per barrel.

Get your daily Invstr Crunch

Get the market news and updates you need, delivered to your inbox or available on our daily podcast.

Risk Disclosure:

Invstr is not a bank and banking services are provided by Vast Bank, N.A.

Brokerage and Banking services are currently only available to U.S. residents.

Invstr app and web services are provided by Invstr Ltd. Advisory services are provided by Invstr Financial LLC, an investment adviser registered with the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC) details of which can be obtained here. Securities brokerage and custody services are provided by Apex Clearing, a broker dealer registered with the SEC and a member of FINRA and SIPC. There is no bank guarantee on securities and securities may lose value.

Investing involves risk and can lead to losses. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Invstr app and web services are provided by Invstr Ltd. Invstr+ advisory services are provided by Invstr Financial LLC, an investment adviser registered with the Securities Exchange Commission (SEC). Securities brokerage and custody services are provided by Apex Clearing, a broker dealer registered with the SEC and a member of FINRA and SIPC. There is no bank guarantee on securities and securities may lose value. Vast Bank N.A. a nationally chartered bank and member of the FDIC, provides the banking products, including the products and services related to digital asset accounts. As with any asset, the value of Digital assets can go up or down and there can be a substantial risk that you lose money buying or holding digital assets. You should carefully consider whether trading or holding Digital assets is suitable for you in light of your financial condition. Your digital account does not support wallet to wallet transferring of your digital assets (i.e. cryptocurrencies) outside the platform. Any Digital Assets in your digital asset account are not insured by any government entities, including but not limited to FDIC or SIPC. The Invstr Visa® Debit Card is issued by Vast Bank, N.A. pursuant to a license from Visa U.S.A Inc and may be used everywhere Visa debit cards are accepted. Invstr Ltd, Invstr Financial LLC and Invstr Securities Ltd are subsidiaries of Marketspringpad Holdings (collectively “Invstr”) and Invstr is solely responsible for the application services and website content.

Watchlists provided when users first access the service are not a recommendation to invest. Instead they are provided to help users better navigate the service. Users are free to edit and create their own watchlists. From time to time, Invstr will suggest instruments solely based on an individual’s interest and the interest levels of the Invstr community. The statistical and portfolio builder models generated by Invstr do not reflect actual investment results and are not guarantees of future results. Comments provided by Invstr leaders, influencers or members of the Invstr Community are not recommendations and should not be construed as such. Invstr does not endorse the content or the positions posted by them. Their investment approach, and that of the models provided by Invstr, may be different from yours and may not be appropriate for you.